Joe: He recreates your first date exactly exactly the way it was a year ago.
Murr: He invites you over to his house and cooks a romantic dinner for the two of you.
Sal: He takes you on a scavenger hunt around New York where the last thing you have to find is him.
Q: He takes you for a walk in the park and the two of you stumble upon a picnic he has set up for the two of you.