ʟᴏɴᴇʟʏ ꜰᴏʀ ʏᴏᴜ ᴏɴʟʏ, ꜰɪɴɴ ᴡᴏʟꜰʜᴀʀᴅ x-ʀᴇᴀᴅᴇʀ

Ｐａｒｔ ５８

Finn's pov

"Y/n and Jack went to see Justin together." Sophia says.
"Y-You saw him, Y-Y/n tell me she's l-lying." My voice cracked with emotion.
She kept looking at me in my eyes,
Sophia is telling the truth.
"F-Finn." She tried to grab my arm but I moved back, I looked at Jack.
How could he hide this from me?
"J-Jack you took her their and didnt tell me?!" I felt so upset.
"Theres more." Sophia says.

Y/n's pov

Seeing Finn with tears in his eyes, holding back. What else does she know.

"Y/n, you've been curious about Finn's ex girlfriend, right?" Sophia asks.
"Uhh w-why?" I ask.
I looked at Finn again he looked worried,
"Well guess what? His ex has been closer than you thought, it's me!" She laughed. I don't know what to feel, my heart beat start to increase. I looked at the ground and started to process it. This whole time, she was right under my nose. Finn was the ex she kept talking about getting back together with. There was like no time to think about it more,

"Y-Y/n." Millie grabbed my shoulder,
They all knew everyone knew.
"You knew." I shook her hand off my shoulder,
"You all knew!" A tear fell down my cheek, then I looked at all of them, even Jack didnt tell me. Jack.
Then I looked around, I just noticed the crowd watching us like it was a show. They all disappeared it was just us in the room to me in my head, I looked back at Finn,

"Finn you lied?" I ask.
"You lied too!" He says.

I felt mad at him, we promised eachother to stop hiding things since the reason we argued so much before we were together was because we hid something from eachother. Promises brake eventually I guess. I feel like I can't even be mad at him as much because I lied and hid something too.

"Your right I did lie." I cry.
I looked down again,
"Why the fuck would you go see him?" He yelled.
"Why did you hide Sophia was your ex?" I yell back, Finn just gulped.

"How do you know about where we went that day?" Jack asks.
"My assistant here followed you two, oh and Y/n I know what Justin did to you two years ago." Sophia wrapped her arm around her assistant.
"How!?" Jack screeched.
"I had a background check on Y/n, turns out a police report came up. Two things happened that day." She says.
"Y-Your sick." I cry.
"Whatever, now you and Finn are done. If you get back together with Finn I'll post the police report." Sophia walked away with her assistant following her again.

Finn's pov

Her eyes were as broken as mine. Sophia ruined everything for me again. I feel like punching Justin. Why the hell would she need to go see him, then hide it from me? I realized then that she must feel exactly the same way I do right now. Then I saw Y/n backing up like if she was about to run out,

Y/n's pov

"Y/n, we can fix this." Finn started to get closer to me,
"Finn get away from me." As soon as I finished that sentence I started to speed walk out the house. I pushed through the crowd around us, they were watching the whole time.

It didnt matter to me though, all that matters is him.

I was about to leave the room we were in but someone grabbed my arm, its Millie with Sadie,
"Y/n wait-" Millie says.
"Why didnt you tell me?" I cry.
Then Jack came too,
"Tiny, hold on let me come with you." Jack says.
"Jack I cant believe you." I cried more thinking about not having Jack next to me while I cry.

I started to speed walk again then when I got outside I went to the side of the house, I looked around to see if anyone saw me. Then I sat down leaning my back on the wall and cried.

Finn's pov

When Y/n walked away, I would have gone after her but a part of me didnt want to. If I went after her she would just keep pushing me away. I looked around and everyone was looking at me. I used my sleeve to wipe my tears on my face. I feel my eyes water again but I hold back as hard as I can. Millie and Sadie went after her. I just stood their not knowing how to move forward.

Then Jack come up to me,
"J-Jack why did you take her to see him?" My voice kept cracking.
"Y/n-"
"Dont say her name." I felt a tear fall down my cheek then I immediately wipe it,
Jack sighed and left the way Y/n went.
"Okay everyone let's call it a night." Jaden announces awkwardly.
The people all looked around then slowly started to leave.

I quickly went to the bathroom hiding from everyone, I didnt want anyone to see me break down. I sat down and cried.

Jack's pov

I went outside looking for Y/n, Finn wouldn't even give me a chance to explain myself. I should have told them to tell eachother before this party. Now I feel like its partly my fault. Sophia is a disgusting person she ruined their relationship in less than 10 minutes and she threatened Y/n.

"Tiny!" I yell.

She couldn't have gotten a ride so quick she would have been here. I looked around where could she have gone. Then I heard sniffing coming from the side of the house. When I went to look I saw her in the dirt crying. I've never seen her cry so hard before. As I walked closer to her I made a noise. She popped up quick and looked up at me,

"Please dont run away from me." I say.
"I should run." She sighed.

I sat down next to her,
"Let me explain." I say.
She put her head down again then cried,
"I didnt know what to do, Finn was really nervous about you knowing-" I admit.
I felt her hair touch my shoulder then her body heat, she rested her head on my shoulder,
"Why did he lie to me Jack?" She cries.
"I wish I could tell you." I wrapped my arm around her,
"I'm sorry I didnt tell you Y/n." I choked up a little telling her sorry,
"Its okay Jack I understand." She says.
"Let's go home, I could stay with you tonight." I say.
"No Jack you should go stay with Finn, he probably needs more attention than me." She wiped some tears.
"Finn is tougher to talk to when hes upset." I sigh.
"Just try for me I dont want him to be alone." She says.
"Okay I'll try for you." I say.
"Did he leave?" She asks.
"I dont think so I'm going to go look for him." I say.
"Okay go." She took her shoulder off my shoulder,
"Wait come on let's get you a ride back to campus." I stand up holding my out to help her up.
"I kinda wanna be alone right now, I'm going to stay here a while." She put her head down again.
"Y/n I wouldnt be a good friend if I left you here." I say.
"Jack please go." She says.
I sighed then looked around,
My suit is covered in dirt,
So was she.

"I'll come back for you Tiny." I say.
"Okay Jack." She sniffed.

Finn's pov

I rarely ever cry the way I have today, she makes me insane. I love her so much. I left the bathroom and immediately ran into Jaden,
"Hey man that was rough out their." He sighs.
"Y-Yeah sorry I-"
"Dont worry about it." He cuts me off.
"Well I'll see you later." I say.
"Hey I know it's none of my business but Y/n is really caring person, if she lied it was for a reason. Keep ur head up man." Jaden says.
"Thanks I appreciate it." I smile a little but still felt more tears wanting to poor out.

I walked through the empty house that was less than 20 minutes ago filled with people, when I got outside I immediately saw Jack come from the side of the house.
_________________________________________

Let me know what you think about the story in the comments, I hope you enjoyed this part♡