The sun shined on the wall.
I laid there in her bed with her head on my chest.
I didn't feel right. I felt guilty for an odd reason. The one thing I couldn't get my mind was Lucy. The things I said to her and the things she said to me. Everything was falling apart.
I got up slowly so Caitlin's head would be let down gently. I started to put my clothes on, looking at the clock, I realized it was 9pm. I tiptoed my way towards the door and down the stairs. I looked back before I opened the door. I had a feeling Caitlin knew why I did what I did. I shook it off and walked out, closing the door slowly behind me.
I walked inside my house and walked into the living room. I laid on the couch and stared at the ceiling. I was fucking up badly. I lost Lucy and that was worst mistake of all. I walked into the kitchen to get me a Sprite. I pulled back the opener and took a sip.
"What did you do?" I heard a voice say.
I jumped and turned on the light to see Ryan.
"What the hell, man?"
"What the hell is going on with you and Lucy?"
"Nothing?" He looks at me, narrowed. And I sighed. "I fucked up. And now, she hates me."
"That's not the first time."
"No man. She genuinely hates me. And I fucked somebody else out of anger."
"You fucked - who?"
I had to lie. I couldn't say Caitlin because that would cause hell and I was already going through it.
"Girl I met at the club."
"Stripper?"
"Nah, a girl from before."
"Huh. Justin, you gotta make this right...again."
"I'm tired of trying. Maybe Lucy and I just aren't meant to be."
-
Next day, I avoided school. I wasn't ready to face Caitlin nor Lucy. I decided to keep playing the same song over and over. I never wrote the lyrics to it, but the chords could tell it was a sad song. A song about her. The times we had. Most of the times I fucked up. I heard the door open and I walked out of my room. I stood there on top of the staircase to see Lucy.
My mom looked up at me. "I'll be out back." She flashes me a smile and walks out towards the back.
Lucy looked up at me with her big brown eyes.
"What do you want?" I asked her.
I was shocked to see she was here.
"To tell you that I'm sorry."
"You are?"
"I said some pretty harsh things. I've been going through a lot."
"That's obvious." She starts walking up the stairs. "I really did care about you. Honest." She caressed my face softly.
I shook her hand off. "I can't do it."
"Do what?"
"I had sex. With someone else."
"Oh." She backed away a little. "I did too." She looks up at me and I look at her confused.
"What? Who?"
"Sean."
-

YOU ARE READING
The Game Plan. • j.b.[EDITING]
FanfictionHe's tricked into a bet, saying he can make any girl fall for him, but what happens when he's the one falling for the girl?