Monsterous Trust (Ticci Toby x Eyeless Jack)

Truth Or Dare

I was just finishing up in a shower when I could hear hoots and hollers, I stopped washing my hair to listen.
(What the fuck...?)
(What's happening?)
I decided to finish up quickly just to see what was going on, once I was out I dried off quickly and got dressed I then left the room, the first person I saw was Clockwork.
"Hey, what's going on?" I asked, "I heard a lot of racket."
"Oh." She said as she turned to me, "Apparently Slender took Sally out for the night."
"That... doesn't exactly explain the hoots and hollers," I said.
"Oh, we're going to play truth or dare later." She said, "Since Slender isn't here to stop us."
"That isn't good." I said.
"Absolutely not." She said, "I know for a fact that things will go badly."
"So we're unsupervised?" I asked.
"Not exactly." She said, "Masky and Hoodie are still here, and Masky said that he was going to watch us just to make sure we don't go too far."
"That's comforting." I said.
"Believe me, it is." She said, "BEN's home, and he's going to go as extreme as possible."
I sighed.
"You wanna come down?" She asked.
(Do it.)
(Oh come on, do it!)
(Yes!)
(Ye-hes!)
"Fine." I caved, "Why not."
She clapped slightly, I followed her downstairs to see just about everyone was down there ready to play, they all seemed excited, Masky and Hoodie were sitting on the couch in a bored manner as everyone else was sitting in a circle on the floor, Toby noticed me and quickly started flailing his arms around, I went over to him and he scooted over, I figured I'd just sit there so I sat on down, I looked at everyone's anticipated expression, I knew something was going to go wrong immediately.
"I'm going to place one rule." Masky said from the couch, "If someone is uncomfortable with the truth they have to tell or the dare, they don't have to do it, understand?"
We all silently agreed, that was a little reassuring, knowing we didn't have to do something we were uncomfortable with.
"Okay, who wants to start?" Jeff asked.
BEN raised his hand, Jeff sighed.
"Alright, fine." He said.
He quickly turned to Jane.
"Truth or dare?' BEN asked.
She thought for a moment.
"Dare." She said.
"I dare you to take your bra off!" BEN shouted.
Both Masky and Hoodie both groaned, Jane sighed and reached into the front of her dress, she messed around a bit before she pulled her bra out of her shirt.
"There." She said as she tossed it.
It landed in the middle of our circle, everyone was dead silent as we stared at it.
"How did you do that?" BEN asked as he looked up at her.
She scoffed slightly.
"It's not that hard to do." She said, "Right?" She turned to Clockwork.
She just shrugged.
"I mean, I do it all the time." She agreed.
"Whoa!" Jeff said.
I gave everyone a weird look.
"Is it really that amazing?" I asked.
They all looked at me.
"What?" I asked, "It's so obvious, it's a girl thing, we'll never understand."
Toby began laughing.
"Okay, now it's my turn." Jane said, "Liu."
"Oh no..." Liu said quietly.
"Truth or dare?" She asked.
"Um..." He trailed off, "Truth?"
"Okay..." She trailed off, "What's your biggest fear?"
He pointed at Jeff.
"That isn't Jeff!" She snapped.
Liu started to think.
"I don't know..." He trailed off, "Centipedes?"
"Centipedes?" Jeff asked.
"Yeah." Liu said, "They could crawl into your ears and eat your brain!"
"That's ridiculous." Jeff scoffed.
"No, it's an actual thing." Masky suddenly spoke up, "In Asian culture, it's a common fear, apparently it's so common that in their mythology Dragons were scared of centipedes for that same reason."
"The more you know." Hoodie said calmly.
"I guess it's my turn..." Liu trailed off.
He started looking at everyone, I watched as it changed from Liu to Sully, it was just the look in his eyes.
"Clocky." He said as he looked at her.
"Dare." She said.
He laughed slightly.
"I dare you to take your pants off." He said.
Masky groaned again, she calmly stood up and pulled her pants down, I couldn't help but crack up laughing, she was wearing basketball shorts underneath her pants, she smiled down at Sully who looked both shocked and horrified.
"Didn't see that coming, did ya?" She asked as she placed her hands on her hips, leaning down to him.
He looked a little pissed off but also embarrassed, Clockwork looked at Toby.
"Truth or dare, Tobes?" She asked.
"Dare!" Toby said as he threw his arms in the air.
"I dare you to take your shirt off." She said.
He immediately grabbed the hem of his sweater and attempted to pull it off, we all sat there and watched him struggle with his clothes for a minute before I decided to actually help, I just grabbed the back of his sweater and shirt and pulled it off him, he immediately made a heroic pose, his hair a mess and his mouthguard out of whack.
"You weirdo." I said quietly.
He laughed as he rocked around a bit.
"It's your turn, Toby." Clockwork said.
"Oh, yup!" Toby said happily, "Uhh..."
He looked around a bunch, his eyes fell on Jeff.
"T-truth or d-dare?!" He asked excitedly.
"Truth." Jeff said.
Toby went dead quiet.
"I f-forget what I was g-gonna ask..." He said quietly as he looked down, "Oh damn..."
We all sat in silence as we waited for him, it looked like he was thinking long and hard.
"Oh for the love of...!" Masky trailed off, "Ask! My god!"
Toby was pulled back to reality with Masky's shouting, he looked at Jeff.
"What were we d-doing?" He asked.
"Truth." I said.
"Oh right!" Toby said, "Jeff, h-have you e-ever lost a st-taring contest?"
We were all quiet.
"I... I don't have eyelids." Jeff said, "I can't blink."
Toby stared at him in silence, obviously not picking up on it, Masky groaned again as I shook my head.
"Toby, he can't blink." I said, "He uses eyedrop to keep his eyes moist."
Toby stared at me, I watched as it slowly dawned on him.
"Oh." Toby said, he slapped his hand against his face, "I'm a moron."
"At least he's figured one thing out." Hoodie said quietly.
I attempted not to laugh.
"Okay, my turn." Jeff said.
He looked around and his eyes stopped on Jane, he then quickly looked at me.
"Truth or dare?" He asked.
I was honestly thinking that I'd just sit through this without any problems, but apparently Jeff wanted to make me suffer, I let out a sigh, I really didn't want to know what question he'd ask me.
"Dare." I said.
Jeff chuckled slightly and my heart sank, I prepared myself for what he was going to say.
"I dare you to French Kiss Jane." He said.
Oh, it wasn't me he wanted to torture.
I looked at Jane and could see the horror in her eyes, I figured I had nothing to lose, maybe it'd even fix the problem I've developed with Toby, but I wasn't just going to do it, I looked at Masky.
"Am I permitted, or...?" I trailed off.
"Why're you asking permission?" Masky asked, "I don't care."
"Alright then." I said as I looked at Jane.
She looked really uncomfortable, I got up and went over to her, I sat in front of her and took off my mask, she didn't do anything.
"Backing down?" Jeff mocked.
She growled at him, she then reached up and took her mask off, she was still rather pretty, even if she was burned alive, she glared at Jeff but I figured I'd keep going, it actually wasn't fully my idea, the demons were very persuasive today.
I grabbed her chin and moved in, she tensed up as soon as our lips made contact, although her mouth was slightly open meaning she was accepting her fate, which is really weird to think about, I slipped my tongue into her mouth and I felt her shudder, I had my eyes open ever so slightly as her eyes were squeezed shut, I could hear everyone laughing quietly at us, I was well aware that I was being used in a horrible way but hey, I don't care, the only problem I was having was the fact that I felt nothing, nothing shifted inside me like what happens with Toby, I was mildly disappointed, but a tiny piece of me in the back of my mind knew that was going to happen.
Her tongue rubbed against my stud and her eyes immediately shot open, her surprise, I will admit, was pretty amusing, the kiss only lasted a few seconds longer before I pulled away, I wiped some saliva off my mouth before I slipped my mask back on, I then scooted back to my spot, she looked both horrified and surprised still as she covered her mouth.
"Y-you... have a tongue ring...?" She asked as she looked at me.
"Oh!" Toby said happily as he looked at me, "You got it b-back in?"
"Yeah, I put it in about a week ago." I said.
"Did it h-hurt?" He asked.
"Not nearly as much as getting my tongue cut out." I said, "But yeah, I guess it did."
"Since when did you have a tongue ring?" Jeff asked.
"Before I was a Creepypasta." I replied, "A friend of mine in high school knew how to do piercings and offered to give me some, but I wanted it somewhere mom wouldn't find it."
I looked down slightly as I scratched the back of my head.
"She found out." I said, "I was back-sassing her and stuck my tongue out."
Toby began laughing at me, I glared at him slightly, I rolled my head at him and looked around, I stopped and looked at BEN.
"Truth or dare, BEN." I said.
"Dare!" He said.
"I dare you to bring all the animals inside." I said.
Everyone looked at me, I felt really proud of myself, it's harmless, but it'd piss off Slender.
"Okay, I'll be back." BEN said as he jumped up.
He ran off and some people started to laugh, this was the best, BEN came back inside with a bunch of animals and sat back down, Smile jumped right onto Jeff, as I was sitting there I felt a presence behind me, I looked up in time to see SeedEater before he plopped down on top of me, I let out a distressed noise as he crushed me, I attempted to push him off as I heard people laughing, I eventually pushed him off.
"Jeez." I said, "I know, it's been awhile."
He went to lay on me again.
"Stop." I said as I pushed him, "You can sit next to me, not on me."
He moved around me a bit before he just sat behind me, we continued to play for a while, most dares were inappropriate, most truths were really personal, no one was really talking to me, at some point Seedy started to pet me, I just let him, he obviously missed me, at some point it was Jane's turn, she looked at Toby.
"Truth or dare?" She asked.
"I'll d-do t-truth this t-time." He said.
"Do you have a crush on anyone in the house?" She asked.
"Yes." Toby replied.
Everybody oohed.
"Who is it?" Clockwork asked.
"I d-don't have t-to answer." Toby said as he folded his arms, "I c-can't d-date anyways."
"Good point." Clockwork said.
Toby looked around a bit before he looked at Laughing Jack.
"LJ, t-truth or d-dare?" Toby asked.
"Dare!" He replied.
"I d-dare you t-to play g-gay chicken with J-Jeff!" Toby said.
Both LJ and Jeff seemed disturbed, I looked at Toby.
"What the hell is gay chicken?" I asked.
"You p-place your hand on s-someone's knee and s-slowly move i-it down their i-inner thigh." Toby explained, "It's u-usually done w-with t-two people of th-the same g-gender."
"Oh." I said.
"The first o-one t-to back d-down is the ch-chicken." Toby said.
Well, this is going to be interesting, Seedy moved away from me and sat near Masky and Hoodie.
"I ain't playing chicken with LJ!" Jeff protested.
"Wuss." Sully said quietly.
Jeff glared at him.
"Fine." Jeff said.
They both looked angry but they actually got closer to each other, there were more hoots and hollers, I just sat silently as I watched, moments before it went too far Masky spoke up.
"That's enough." Masky said.
They both looked relieved as they stopped, I had a stupid smile on my face, that was super entertaining, LJ looked around and stopped, his eyes on me, I didn't like the look in his eyes.
"Truth or dare?" He asked.
"Dare." I said, preparing for the worst.
"I dare you to go stand in the closet." He said.
My heart leaped as my eyes widened.
"No!" I said, "I'm not standing in the closet!"
"Why not?!" LJ asked angrily.
"The rule was already placed, I don't have to do it." I growled, "Just move on."
He stared at me.
"Wow, I didn't know Eyeless Jack could be such a wuss." Sully said.
I didn't care how much anyone insulted me, I wasn't getting in closet, everyone started to heckle me except for the proxies, I was getting annoyed but I didn't care, nothing can convince me to get in the closet.
"Enough!" Masky shouted, "Just leave him alone!"
"Guys, seriously." Hoodie said.
LJ suddenly jumped up and grabbed me, I wasn't given any time to react before I was shoved into the closet, the door was slammed behind me and I quickly turned around and attempted to open the door, I could hear faint laughter on the other side, I quickly turned around and pressed my back against the door, staring at the opposite wall, the hair on the back of my neck stood up, I looked around desperately, my breathing was getting heavy, I began trying to calm myself down along with the demons, I began freaking out when the walls slowly started to close in on me, I fumbled slightly before I found the doorknob, I desperately tried to get it to turn, nothing was happening, the walls were getting closer and I tried to move away, the ceiling was even starting to close in, I slid down the door as I looked around, I placed my leg against the wall and tried to push it away but it wasn't working, I grabbed my head, digging my nails into my scalp, I tried to push the wall away again as I closed my eyes, it was overwhelming, I couldn't breathe.
"Stop...!" I said quietly, "Stop...! Stop...! STOP IT!"
When I felt the walls begin to crush me I started screaming, trying to protect myself by curling into a ball, I was dying.

I was staring at the ceiling in the living room, I was still breathing heavily as my body was shaking, I had a cloth of some sort on my forehead, I looked around slightly when I realized someone was talking to me, I saw both Masky and Hoodie were next to me, Hoodie was talking calmly to me, almost the same way he talked to Masky when he was having a breakdown, I could also hear Jane and Toby yelling at everyone, I let out a groan.
"I think he's coming out of it." Masky said.
"Jack?!" Toby asked as he quickly knelt down next to me.
I stared at him in silence before I started to cry, and this wasn't even any normal crying, no, I was bawling, never had I ever cried that much before, for a split moment no one knew what to do, Toby was the first one to react and quickly pulled me up, he held me close as he attempted to comfort me, I leaned on his shoulder as I cried heavily, I really thought I was going to die, I really thought the walls were going to crush me.
"I think we're done." I heard Masky say, "You guys really took it too far."
"How were we supposed to know he was claustrophobic?!" LJ asked angrily.
"The fact that he refused the dare!" Masky snapped, "I only gave you guys one rule and you didn't listen!"
I heard Seedy shout something, then there was a scream, I looked up to see he was attempting to attack LJ and Jeff, my legs twitched.
"S-Seedy!" Toby snapped.
He stopped and looked at Toby, he grunted.
"Seed... kill..." He said.
"There's m-more import-tant things r-right now." Toby said.
He started coming over, sitting near us and growling at everyone, Toby rubbed my back slightly as he looked up at Seedy.
"W-will you take h-him back t-to the room?" He asked.
Seedy nodded and reached down, he grabbed me around the waist and picked me up, he started to carry me off as I looked at Toby, he cracked his knuckles before he leaped onto LJ, I was then carried upstairs, I could hear Toby cursing along with Masky and Hoodie trying to pull him off who he was attacking, Seedy took me to the room and laid me on the bed, I sat there trembling as Seedy climbed onto the foot of my bed, he grabbed me again and pulled me close, he started to pet me, the two of us were sitting there silently until the door to the room was forced open, Masky and Kate threw Toby into the room before they closed the door, he got up quickly and flipped off the door, he then looked at me and Seedy, he got off the floor and came over, he sat on the edge of the bed.
"Are you okay?" He asked.
I nodded.
"I'm okay." I said, "I... guess it could have been worse."
"What happened?" Toby asked, "I've n-never seen you f-freak out l-like that."
I was quiet.
"I've been claustrophobic for as long as I remember." I said, "When I'm in a tight space with no exits the walls close in and crush me."
"Whoa, r-really?" He asked, "That s-sounds awful."
"It is." I said as I looked down, "That one was... pretty bad, but not nearly as bad as when I first discovered it."
He was quiet, I let out a slight sigh.
"I guess... I was about six or something." I said, "I don't remember exactly, it's been a while."
Seedy made a little noise as he squished my cheeks, knocking my mask off, I pushed his hands away from me.
"One of the neighbor kids shoved me into a bucket and closed the lid on me." I continued, "I was actually hospitalized because of it."
"Oh..." Toby said as he looked around, "But... isn't it all j-just in your h-head?"
"Yeah, I know." I said, "That's how I attempt to convince myself I'm fine, but it doesn't work."
He looked a little sad.
"Does it... actually c-crush you?" He asked.
"Feels like it." I replied, "I always try to push the wall away from me but it never works, and I guess that's because the wall doesn't actually move."
He just nodded, I sighed as Seedy somewhat covered my face, I just let him this time, Toby was quiet as he watched the two of us.
"He r-really likes you." Toby said.
"Yeah, I know." I said as I moved his hands slightly, "It's probably because I feed him."
He rested his chin on the top of my head.
"Or maybe... it's a cannibal thing?" I basically questioned.
Toby chuckled slightly.
"I wonder i-if Slender w-would be m-mad if we j-just let him stay h-here." Toby said, "But I h-honestly don't c-care what he thinks at this p-point."
I couldn't help but smile at him, he really was the best thing to me, a really good friend.