Slasher x Reader Drabbles & Imagines ||Requests Open||

🔪~!PolyScream Fighting Over S/O~🔪

Randy Meeks, Sidney Prescott, Tatum Riley, Stu Matcher, Billy Loomis x Reader

Requested by xxxwitchcaftxxx on Tumblr

Y'all how much chlorine can a person drink-

It does not matter how the fight started– all I'm saying is Tatum or Stu is winning it. No, I do not take criticism on this matter. (I kidd)

You are just sitting back watching everyone lose their utter minds over you for whatever reason (most likely choosing who gets to sit next to you for movie nights) but suddenly in the middle of the fight, Tatum and Stu become the loudest and eventually the only ones fighting.

It gets ugly too.

Tatum is pulling out all the stops digging into Stu's and everyone else's issues while Stu is just spewing utter nonsense only really half-listening to whatever Tatum is saying. Overall these two will most likely end up with whatever they want with you after the others get tired of their yelling. Could definitely see her getting caught up in the moment and going off on everyone– even you for no reason.

Sidney is quieter in the situation, trying desperately to maintain peace and find a rational solution while being primarily on your side. Will most likely just end up saying "I'm done," or sighing and just standing/sitting by you watching everything go down. If it is something of actual importance or something she feels strongly about though all it takes is one yell from her and everyone is silent immediately.

Randy, now he will be splitting his unconditional support for you and Sidney– unless it's something Randy also wants in on. Then he's most likely going to try fighting Stu or Billy while Stu just fights Tatum. Poor Randy is just being ignored no matter how hard he's trying to join the bickering. Might try to jump on Stu and physically fight someone– not one of the girls though. He had to be a gentleman. Even after Tatum sucker punches him.

Billy now– this depends on his mood and how his day went. He will either be on Stu's side. being more of a background puppetmaster. telling Stu what to say and saying little comments, or he will be violent. Billy is a put-together person because he has to be not because he naturally is. Things bother him like everyone else and if you push him far enough he's pushing you back. Now whether that be metaphorically or literally depends. If Billy however does not get violent or become Stu's voice in the back of his head he is either the cause for said argument or could care less about whatever is being discussed.

Now with you. Either you sit back with a bowl of popcorn and soda watching the drama unfold or you get involved yourself. A quick way to stop a fight about you, just stand up and speak up. In the end, if it's about you it's really your choice as it would be for anyone in the group if the fight was about them.

While I do say you all getting into quite a few squabbles, as all couples do, most would end up being small and insignificant easily defusable situations. Just because of the mix of personalities. When you're dating Stu's with his general lack of filter, Tatums, and her wonderful fiery attitude, Billy, and his homicidal tendencies, Sidney, and her mom group but don't be fooled shell floor a bitch energy, and Randy and his overall leader simp and movie nerd personality you're bound to find something that someone disagrees about.

At the end of the day though no matter what the fight was about everyone loves each other– well with Billy you never know– but for the most part, it will be long make-up sessions for whatever fights happen during the daytime.

The voices around you were loud and angry. It was annoying and threatening to give you a splitting headache.

Tatum was yelling pointing from you to Stu as venom flew from her lips. Stu on the other hand was almost having a conversation with himself entirely as he simply screamed near unintelligible words that truly contributed nothing but chaos and immature insults to an already ridiculous situation. While this was going on, Billy fumed glaring at Randy from afar who only stood near Stu trying to back up Tatum and Sidney despite the fact that Tatum was capable of defending herself and that Sidney was sitting next to you. She was tired and slouching back letting the sofa consume her with a look of pure confusion on her face as Stu stuck his thumb under his nose and lifted it imitating a pig's nose as he stuck his tongue out at an offended Tatum who audibly gasped.

"You take that back you fucking dick!" she cried lunging at Stu– Randy barely had enough time to catch her, stopping Tatum from murdering the laughing Stu.

Sighing you stood, your voice cutting through the anger floating through the air "Enough!" you yelled, the brief silence seeming like paradise to your throbbing head. "I don't even like them," you stated throwing your hands up before letting your palms slap back down against your thighs. With that, the entire fight was disbanded.

Everyone looked at you with surprise and confusion. Suddenly Stu turned to you arms outstretched and knees slightly bent "They don't like them!" he cheered forgetting the intense battle he and Tatum were previously engaged in. "What don't they like?" Stu whispered leaning over to Tatum who simply shrugged, equally confused.

Normal conversations returned and everyone like that was back to their usual selves.

"I think we need a group cuddle to heal all our hurt–" Stu stated loudly letting out a faux sob a hand over his heart "feelings." he breaths out wiping away fake tears.

"Has anyone told you how clingy you are Stu?" Randy asked scoffing as he sat down on the sofa next to you and Sidney. As soon as he was facing Stu's direction once more the air was knocked from his lungs. "Yes, thanks for volunteering by the way," Stu chided his long arms wrapping around Randy as he latched onto him.

Stu let out an over-exasperated sigh of contentment as Billy and Tatum joined the group on the sofa.

"Real nice of you Randy," Billy agreed, teasing the brunette.