Herbert West, Sidney Prescott, Tatum Riley, Dwight Riley |Dewey|, Ranky Meeks, Hannibal Lecter, Carrie White, Baby Firefly x Reader
Here's that part 2. Now off to write Heisenberg smut and stuff people actually read-
Herbert West
Herbert would be damned if he let you win- oh and look at that he lost.
Herbert will go into the pillow fight thinking it to be over quickly. Just a short little fight and he could go back to his experiments, right? Wrong. All it took was one perfectly aimed hit and Herbert's glasses were flung somewhere on the carpet of your shared bedroom. But [Y/n] surely you would let the man fetch his glasses right? Wrong again, this is war and Herbert was going down!!!
He is extremely butt hurt about it. Insisting you cheated by not letting him fetch his glasses and demanding rematches. If you tease him about it his face will flush and he'll storm away only to surprise attack you later.
Sidney Prescot
She is winning... on accident.
Let's be honest before Sidney is traumatized by Stu & Billy she's a total sweetheart– that is totally willing to punch a bitch if needed. Will most likely end up winning accidentally. She had planned to have some fun with it, play around, and let you win. Maybe sneak in a few kisses. Plan instantly derailed when she took the first swing and you had tumbled into her bedside table hitting the side of your head on the corner. A fun night quickly turned into an ER visit and lots of apologetic cuddles.
Won't tease you about it and will be constantly apologizing insisting she took no pride in winning after you playfully brought it up.
Tatum Riley
She is winning- no question about it.
Tatum was the one to actually suggest the pillow fight when you were staying over one night. Oh, just a friendly little game. Sure, we'll laugh, have fun. Nothing serious. Well needless to say as soon as you had agreed Tatum went crazy grabbing the nearest pillow and absolutely destroying you with it. You hadn't even had the chance to grab a pillow before you were calling your defeat.
She will be sad it ended and will tease you for it. "Your first time or something?" She'll cheekily ask from where she was sitting on you holding a pillow threateningly.
Randy Meeks
This man will be apologizing for his victory in advance before being absolutely folded by you.
Randy was so confident talking himself up as he readied himself. As soon as the first hit landed though the poor man was overwhelmed squeaking in protest as you pummeled him without remorse all while yelling "Who's winning now," with a laugh.
Is butt hurt at his defeat but as soon as you open your arms for cuddles his grudge is forgotten in favor of diving into your side.
Dwight Riley |Dewey|
Acts like he's going to win but in the end overdramatically loses.
While he's having fun with the pillow fight, goading you playfully and groaning when you hit him in the end he's letting you win. After a good amount of time the next time you hit him he is doubling over dropping his pillow and dramatically falling backward. "The light," he'll say through a smile holding back a laugh "I see it," and death. As soon as you jump on him cheering your victory he is tackling you however turning the tables.
No teasing but expect lots of kisses and some tickling. Dewey is just so happy and seeing the joy in your eyes at the heart-warming play fight just makes Dewey's heart throb in his chest. Will be muttering something wonderfully sappy like "You know I think you just may be the most beautiful in all of Woodsboro when you smile like that,"
Hannibal Lecter
Will let you think you've won only to sweep your victory from under your feet.
Hannibal was unsure of the idea at first but accepted and actually found himself having fun. He will be chuckling alongside you playfully batting at you and dodging in return. Near the end of the fun little game Hannibal was pushed into a corner of the bedroom, not good. You had said while preparing the final blow. Sadly for you in that moment Hannibal had rushed forward tackling you and sending you to the ground with him on top. Hannibal cushioned your landing making sure you didn't hurt yourself with a smile. "Looks like I won."
Hannibal will tease you about it for a little bit. His teasing comes in the form of mocking cooes as he cheekily says "Maybe next time," a peck on the cheek "Or maybe not."
Carrie White
You let her win.
The poor girl was terrified as you handed her the pillow telling her to give it her all. "But, what if I were to hurt you?" after you soothe her worries she'll actually enjoy it as long as it doesn't get too rough. Finally, she understands why the kids in her old class did this. It was fun. In the end, you let her take you down enjoying how she's smiling from where she is on top of you laughing in victory.
Won't tease you and will actually praise you. Carrie will tell you how great of a job you did and how she can't believe she won.
Baby Firefly
She wins and doesn't stop there.
Another one who is the first to suggest it. She will just stand up randomly throwing a pillow at you before lunging your way with a pillow of her own nestled between her hands. While the both of you go at it for a while eventually you tumble to the ground, your pillow out of reach. Even as you nervously chuckle editing defeat Baby only smiles down at you before pelting you with the pillow in her grasp all while laughing. She's only stopping when she loses her own footing and topples on top of you laughing out an "Oops. Got a lil bit too excited their baby bug."
Baby firefly won't tease you– much. Also, don't expect to get up from your spot on the ground anytime soon. She'll be cuddling you right then and there, peppering you with kisses while locking you in her arms.

YOU ARE READING
Slasher x Reader Drabbles & Imagines ||Requests Open||
FanfictionA collection of slasher drabbles & imagines by yours truly! This book is filled with a large variety of slashers/horror characters along with some final girls and random side characters. (All in list on first part and if the character you want is ab...