Red Dead Redemption II Preferences and Oneshots

Arthur Morgan: Dreamy

Arthur Morgan X Female Reader

Summary: Before Blackwater your best friend, Sean, got you to admit that you have feelings for Arthur. He promised to keep your secret but when he returns and the gang throw a party, the alcohol and excitement makes him spill everything to Arthur Morgan himself.

Word Count: 2900

Sean wasn't really the person that most people would tell their secrets too but he was your best friend. He knew you well and he knew when you were hiding something from him. He knew when you were attracted to someone and he knew when you had feelings for someone, that's exactly what led to this conversation.

It had happened before Blackwater, before everything went wrong. You were in the camp along with everyone else but you and Sean were sitting off somewhere by yourselves.

Sean had been rambling about one of his stories, normally you loved to listen to his stories. You loved the way that his face would light up as he over exaggerated every little detail but this time you just couldn't pay attention.

Why couldn't you pay attention? Arthur fucking Morgan, that's why. He captivated your attention most of the time on a normal day but you swear he was actually trying to give you a heart attack today.

There he was, in all his glory, Arthur Morgan chopping wood for the camp. The sleeves of his shirt were rolled up to his elbow, which was oddly erotic anyway, and the top few buttons of his shirt were undone. Giving you just a peak at his chest. Every time he swung the axe you could see his muscles moving under his shirt, it was hypnotic. You couldn't help but smile as he wiped his forehead with the back of his hand and squinted when the sun shone in his eyes. The whole thing was like a scene out one of your more R-rated dreams.

"Are you even listening to me?" Sean asked as he waved his hand in front of your face.

"What? Yeah, of course" you nodded as you turned your attention back to him, pretending that you had heard everything that he said.

"Oh, I see. Sorry, I can't keep you entertained like King Arthur over there" Sean apologised sarcastically.

"What are you talking about?" you asked, acting clueless despite the pink tint making its way to your face.

"What? Should I take my shirt off and get all sweaty, then will you pay attention to me?" he asked playfully, gesturing towards himself.

"You're gross" you groaned, shaking your head at him.

"Come on, tell me. What's so dreamy about Mr Morgan?" Sean asked, leaning towards you with a cocky smirk on his face.

"Ugh, Sean, stop" you groaned again as you hid your face in your hands. You thought that you were pretty good at hiding your feelings for Arthur, perhaps you were wrong.

"Oh relax, I already know that you like him. I'm just messing with ya" he teased, knocking his shoulder against yours.

"Wha-how? How do you know?" you asked, looking up at him with widened eyes. How long had he known for?

"So, you do? Do you admit it? You find Arthur dreamy?" Sean asked, the smile on his face only growing as your blush deepened.

"Fine, yes, I admit it. I have feelings for Arthur" you sighed, looking down at the ground in front of you.

"I knew it!" Sean cheered as he jumped up out of his seat, catching the attention of a few people, including Arthur.

"Will you sit down and be quiet" you hissed as you grabbed his arm and pulled him back down onto his seat while he just laughed. Your face was bright red now as you waited for everyone to carry on with what they had been doing, they were pretty used to Sean's loudness at this point.