Red Dead Redemption II Preferences and Oneshots

You're Scarily Calm when Angry

Arthur-

Arthur was confused when he first saw you that angry but he soon warmed up to it. He could admit that you were kind of terrifying when you went that calm with anger but it definitely amused him to see you scare other people without even making a single threat. He always got to see the kind and soft side of you so it kind of amused him to see you scaring somebody like that. In the camp, your anger is usually turned towards Micah and Arthur loved to watch you calmly taking him on. Micah always backs down first and Arthur couldn't love you more in those moments.

Dutch-

The first time that Dutch saw your Scarily calm anger, he was a little taken back and it threw him a little. But watching you scare the poor guy until you got what you and Dutch wanted impressed him. He definitely planned on using it to his advantage, your anger turned out to be a great asset. When your anger is turned on him, Dutch definitely gets scared. Sometimes he wonders if you would actually kill him or something when you were mad at him. At least that means that Dutch wouldn't do wrong by you. He loves you and secretly thinks that your anger is kinda badass.

Micah-

Micah doesn't understand it at first. Why are you not getting mad? Why aren't you shouting? Why aren't you screaming and fighting? The calm look on your face is just confusing to him, you should be angry about this. Now, he dreads that calm demeanour. When he sees you go that calm, he actually finds himself a little bit antsy to find out what you will do next because he knows that you are about to explode. He knew it meant that you were about to kill whoever was making you this angry. However, when that calm face is pointed towards him, he actually finds himself a little nervous. Were you going to kill him? No you wouldn't do that, would you? He knows that he isn't going to be allowed to sleep in your shared tent tonight. When you're angry at someone else and Micah sees you turn scarily calm, he is excited to find out what you would do next, it might turn him on just a little to see you so in control just before you destroy the person angering you.

Charles-

In a way Charles is thankful that you can control your anger, that you don't let it get the best of you. He respects that you don't turn to violence when somebody makes you angry. He likes how you can still think clearly when you are angry about something. The only time he found your anger less than desirable was when you used him as a treat. It's not a secret that he can look rather intimidating but you were angry with somebody once, you basically used Charles as your muscle. You used him as a threat. At first he was just a little surprised but he soon thought it was amusing. However, he still might just pull you away from the situation.

Javier-

Sure, Javier could get angry but you wouldn't say that he had a bad temper, he could usually control himself. However, you did know that he could be pretty scary when he wanted to be but he had never seen you very angry, he hadn't seen you when you were scary. When Javier saw you drop into that scarily calm state, he wasn't really sure what was going on. But when he saw you scare off a man with pretty much just one look, he was impressed. After you had calmed down he would kind of be like "what the hell was that?!" but he would be impressed and even more proud to be with you.

Sean-

Sean is a loud man, he is loud when he is excited and loud when he is angry. When he is angry, he will threaten and shout and scream. The opposite to you. He would be a little confused by how calm you seemed to be while you softly made threats to the person angering you. Then, he became a little scared of you. Not like he thought you would hurt him or anything, he just didn't know what you would do next or if you would actually go through with your threats. When you turn that calm anger on to him, Sean is terrified. He will instantly apologised and try to make it up to you, he never wants to be on the receiving end of your scarily calm anger. But that didn't make him love you any less. Actually he loved you more. When he sees you getting angry at someone else, your face turning scarily calm, he just looks at you with the biggest heart eyes. Totally loves it. May be a little turned on by it even if it scares him a little.