*late September 1982*
Karen plans an anniversary party for (Y/N) and Andy
Karen's POV:
(Y/N) and Andy have been so busy and everyone knows I love surprising them so I'm planning a anniversary party for them.
Since they are celebrating 2 years of marriage and 4 years together, we are renting out Hillstreet Blue.
I have made out the guest list and made sure to invite Andy's brothers and sister in law too.
(Y/N) has done so much for me over the years plus co-producing her album as well makes me feel like I want to show her how much I appreciate her.
I found a local bakery who can replicate (Y/N) and Andy's original wedding cake flavor of pistachio and cherry.
I got the reservation put in for Hillstreet, made all the invitations and mailed them out.
I called Barry to discuss the plans to make sure (Y/N) and Andy didn't know what we were planning.
"Hello?" Barry answered.
"Hey Barry its Karen," I replied.
"Heyyy how are you?" he responded.
"I'm good how are you?" I replied.
"I'm good too. So for the party, we are gonna fly in and pretend that we are rehersing for a concert. Then, we will take Andy to meet up with you and (Y/N) at Hillstreet Blue and "pretend" we run into each other," Barry explained.
"Ok that sounds like a solid plan! I'll try and keep her busy at the studio or shopping," I responded.
"Then it be like oh it's you guys what's going on kind of situation," Barry said laughing.
"It'll be like a coincidence," I told him laughing.
"Yes a very weird coincidence," Barry said still laughing.
"Mo and Robin will kind of distract Andy in rehersal or pretend the concert was canceled or something along those lines. I will also accidentally mess up Andy's clothes so he can put on the nice satin shirt we bought him," Barry finished explaining.
"I'll make sure to make it seem that some press people are coming to the studio and (Y/N) can dress to the nines right away," I said while curling the telephone line around my finger.
"We will make sure to call you when we leave so you can leave about the same time," Barry said.
"That sounds perfect. Herb is in on this as well as Richard so everything will hopefully fall into line," I replied.
"Oh good! Well we rented out a little space to play music but it's not for a real concert so l et's hope Andy falls for it," Barry replied.
"Oh he fell for (Y/N) so he'll fall for this. He's so in love with her," I replied to Barry.
"We know he doesn't ever stop talking about her," Barry said chuckling.
"The good thing is the whole restruant will be rented out so no one will bother us," I told him.
"I'm glad about that. Sometimes people forget we are human. Oh hold on, Maurice is asking me something," Barry said distracted.
"Ok," I replied.
"Do you want us all to perform a little something at the restaurant?" Barry asked.
"We can plan something if you want?" I asked.
"Why don't we sing like How Deep Is Your Love or We've Only Just Begun?" Barry asked.
"We can talk more about this later if you want?" I replied.
"Yes sounds good. I better go Robin is giving me the look that we need to go to the studio," Barry said lightly laughing.
"Ok bye Barry. Talk to you soon," I replied hanging up.
Everything was falling into place to make (Y/N) and Andy have a night they won't forget.
YOU ARE READING
Taken Too Seriously- An Andy Gibb/Karen Carpenter What If Fanfiction
Historical Fiction(Y/N) is feeling blue. Everything she loves revolves around the 1970s. During a thunderstorm, she's basking in her bedroom playing her favorite ABBA album when her emotions push her over the edge. In anger, she sc...
